Radical Candor
Care personally and challenge directly, at the same time. Most people think they must pick one. Honest feedback given with real care is the kindest thing a manager can do.
by Kim Scott ยท 7 ideas
Care personally and challenge directly, at the same time. Most people think they must pick one. Honest feedback given with real care is the kindest thing a manager can do.
Ruinous empathy is caring without challenging, like holding back criticism to be nice. It feels kind but keeps people from improving, and it's the most common mistake managers make. Say the hard thing, kindly and soon.
Challenging without caring, like blunt criticism with no warmth. People hear the attack, not the message. It's still better than silence, but add care so the feedback lands.
Manipulative insincerity is neither caring nor challenging, like praising someone to their face and criticizing them behind their back. It usually comes from wanting to be liked or fearing conflict, and it kills trust. Say your criticism directly to the person, with care.
Before giving criticism, ask for it yourself and take it well. Ask what you could do differently, then wait through the silence. It shows you mean it and makes honesty safe for everyone.
Give feedback quickly, in person, and about the work, never the personality. Public praise spreads good examples. Private criticism is easier to hear and act on.
Rock stars are great people who grow steadily and want stability in a role they love. Superstars grow fast and want new challenges all the time. A team needs both, so manage each by what they want, not by one idea of ambition.