The Strategy of Conflict

by Thomas C. Schelling · 8 ideas

  1. Mixed Motives

    Most conflicts are not pure contests where one side's gain is the other's loss. Rivals usually share some interest too, like a company and its workers who both lose from a long strike. Find the outcome you both want to avoid, and bargain from there.

  2. Focal Points

    A focal point is the answer that stands out to everyone, like the main entrance at noon when you forgot to pick a meeting place. Deals settle the same way, on round numbers or an even split. To reach agreement, offer the option both sides will see as obvious.

  3. Clear Lines Hold

    Limits that are easy to name, like "none at all" or a round number, are hard to cross without everyone noticing. Fuzzy limits like "a little more" keep sliding, since each step looks like the last. Draw your limits where crossing them is obvious.

  4. Tie Your Hands

    In bargaining, the side that cannot give in often wins, because the other side must adjust. A seller whose prices are set by head office can't be talked down. Limit your own room to move in ways the other side can see, and notice when they do it to you.

  5. Threats and Promises

    A threat costs you only if it fails and you must act, while a promise costs you only if it works and you must pay. Both work only if the other side believes you will follow through later. Make only ones you would keep, and make them hard to take back.

  6. Risk as Pressure

    People rarely believe you will choose an outcome that hurts you both. They do believe things might get out of hand, since then nobody has to choose. When someone raises a risk neither of you controls, decide early how much of it you will accept.

  7. Out of Reach

    In a standoff, the side that can't be reached often wins. A driver who never looks your way at a narrow crossing gets to go first, because no signal from you can change their mind. Before you rely on pressure, make sure the other side can actually hear it.

  8. Trust in Small Steps

    When two sides don't trust each other, a big deal stalls because whoever goes first can be cheated. Split it into small steps where each side gives a little at a time, so no single betrayal costs much. Each kept step builds the trust needed for the next.

More on thinking